Insurance Adjuster Tricks After a Car Wreck in Austin — Do Not Fall for These Tactics

The phone call usually comes within a day or two of your car wreck. A friendly, sympathetic insurance adjuster reaches out to check on your condition, ask a few questions, and maybe even offer a quick settlement to help you with immediate expenses. It feels like the insurance company is on your side, and that is exactly what they want you to believe. In reality, that adjuster’s job is to close your claim for the lowest possible amount, and everything they say and do is carefully designed to accomplish that goal. Shaw Cowart’s personal injury lawyers in Austin have seen these tactics destroy legitimate claims, and the firm makes sure its clients never walk into an insurance company trap unprepared.

Insurance adjusters who handle car wreck claims are trained negotiators backed by billions of dollars in corporate resources. They know that most people have never been through the claims process before and are vulnerable to pressure, confusion, and the lure of fast cash when bills are piling up. They know that a recorded statement taken in the first 48 hours after a wreck — when the victim is still in pain, on medication, and emotionally shaken — is far more likely to contain admissions and inconsistencies that can be weaponized later. They also know that early settlement offers, even generous-sounding ones, are almost always a fraction of what the claim is actually worth if the victim pursues it properly. Shaw Cowart’s car wreck lawyers level the playing field for Austin residents who are dealing with insurance companies that have no intention of being fair.

Understanding how insurance adjusters operate is your first line of defense after a car wreck in Austin. The tactics they use are not random — they follow a playbook refined over decades of claims handling, and every move is designed to protect the company’s bottom line at your expense. Lawyers who handle car wreck cases in the Austin area recognize these strategies instantly and know how to counter each one to protect your claim and maximize your recovery.

The Recorded Statement Trap

One of the first things an adjuster will ask for is a recorded statement about the wreck. They will frame it as routine, telling you it is just standard procedure to process your claim. What they do not tell you is that the statement is being recorded specifically to find anything you say that can be used to reduce or deny your claim later. If you say your neck “feels a little stiff” instead of describing severe pain, the adjuster will later argue that your injuries were minor. If you say “I think the light was green” instead of “the light was green,” they will question your certainty about fault.

You are not legally required to give a recorded statement to the other driver’s insurance company. Politely decline and tell them to direct all communications to your lawyer. This single step can prevent enormous damage to your claim.

The Quick Settlement Offer

Adjusters know that injured victims are dealing with medical bills, vehicle repair costs, and lost income. They also know that most people underestimate the total cost of their injuries because they do not yet know the full extent of treatment they will need. By offering a quick settlement — often within the first week — the insurer hopes to close the file before you discover that your herniated disc needs surgery, that your concussion symptoms will persist for months, or that your physical therapy will cost far more than you expected.

Once you accept a settlement and sign a release, you cannot reopen the claim. The insurance company knows this, and they are banking on your urgency and inexperience to lock you into a number that is far below what your case is worth.

Disputing Your Injuries and Treatment

If you do not accept the early offer, the adjuster shifts to a different strategy: attacking the legitimacy of your injuries. They may argue that the damage to your vehicle was too minor to have caused the injuries you are claiming. They may request access to years of your medical history, searching for any prior complaint involving your neck, back, or head that they can blame your current symptoms on. They may hire a doctor who has never examined you to review your records and write a report saying your treatment was excessive or unnecessary.

These tactics are designed to wear you down and make you feel like your claim is not worth fighting for. An experienced legal team will counter them with objective medical evidence, expert opinions from your treating physicians, and a clear demonstration of the connection between the wreck and your injuries.

Delaying Your Claim

Sometimes the most effective tactic is simply doing nothing. Adjusters may take weeks to return phone calls, lose paperwork that has to be resubmitted, or claim that they need additional documentation before they can move forward. The goal is to drag the process out until you become frustrated enough to accept whatever they offer just to make it end. Every month of delay is another month you are carrying the financial burden of someone else’s negligence.

How to Protect Yourself

Do not give a recorded statement without a lawyer. Do not accept any settlement offer without understanding the full scope of your injuries and treatment needs. Do not sign medical record releases that give the insurer unlimited access to your history. And most importantly, do not assume that the adjuster is working in your interest — they are not. Contact a qualified legal team that handles car wreck cases in Austin, and let them deal with the insurance company while you focus on your recovery. Texas gives you two years to file a personal injury lawsuit, but the strongest claims are built by people who get legal help early and refuse to let the insurance company control the narrative.

Here are more locations we serve around Austin, Texas
Cedar Park
George Town
Hutto
Kyle
Leander
Pflugerville
Round Rock
San Marcos